Answer: Vague instructions like 'Add a user stats endpoint' fail because they are unspecific about what stats to include, mention no data sources, reference no existing patterns, and are missing test requirements. Status: Confirmed Entry: tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples Revision: 1 Digest: sha256:2fa8c90b2c519930 (changes whenever the content changes) Timeline: Created: 2026-11-13T03:14:38Z Last changed: 2026-11-13T03:14:38Z Last verified: 2026-11-20T12:45:44Z Next check: 2026-11-21T12:45:44Z Check interval: Daily Expected change: No fixed schedule Data: Field | Value | Source | As of bad instruction | Add a user stats endpoint. | [1] | 2026-11-20 reason 1 | Unspecific about what stats to include | [1] | 2026-11-20 reason 2 | No mention of data sources | [1] | 2026-11-20 reason 3 | No reference to existing patterns | [1] | 2026-11-20 reason 4 | Missing test requirements | [1] | 2026-11-20 Sources: [1] Cognition. "Good vs. Bad Instructions". https://docs.devin.ai/essential-guidelines/good-vs-bad-instructions.md Role: primary. Accessed: 2026-11-20T12:45:44Z Quote: ""Add a user stats endpoint."" (Supports: bad instruction) Quote: "Unspecific about what stats to include" (Supports: reason 1) Quote: "No mention of data sources" (Supports: reason 2) Quote: "No reference to existing patterns" (Supports: reason 3) Quote: "Missing test requirements" (Supports: reason 4) Published: 2026-11-20T09:56:00Z Snapshot SHA-256: dc31e1ae9fd32f3b7f7a0e265754184f6ec788dc85663ac4a189f9736f2406e0 (captured 2026-11-13T03:14:38Z) Verification: Method: Automated extraction from [1] with deepseek-flash (JSON output, thinking disabled). Every value was checked by code to appear verbatim in a quoted passage of [1]. On this check the text of [1] was unchanged since 2026-11-13T03:14:38Z, so the values verified then were kept. Cross-check: not-available at 2026-11-20T12:45:44Z. No independent second source is configured for this entry Last successful check: 2026-11-20T12:45:44Z Last attempt: 2026-11-20T12:45:44Z Notes and limitations: Extracted automatically from a single official source (section "Good vs. Bad Instructions"). Related: https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bot-instructions-modes What modes and instructions can I configure for a Devin Bot? https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bug-fix-prompt-template What Devin prompt template should I use to fix a specific bug? https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/build-custom-orchestrator How do I build a custom orchestrator for Devin Outposts? https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/api-endpoint-prompt-template What Devin prompt template exists for adding a new API endpoint? https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/archive-delete-bot How do I archive or delete a Devin Bot? https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/assign-fixes-to-devin How do I assign security fixes to Devin? https://latestn.com/tool/ All entries in AI tools Change log: Time | Event | Change | Source 2026-11-13T03:14:38Z | added | Entry created | — Changes for this entry as a feed: https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples/latest Challenge this entry: Open challenges: None How: If a value here is wrong or out of date, send what is wrong and a link to evidence. Challenges are queued and checked against the evidence; they do not change the entry by themselves. If the entry changes as a result, the change log says so. Form: https://latestn.com/dispute/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples POST: https://latestn.com/dispute/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples with claim, evidence_url, and optionally field and contact (form-encoded or JSON) GET: https://latestn.com/dispute/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples?claim={what is wrong}&evidence_url={link} How to cite: LatestN. (2026). Why do vague instructions like 'Add a user stats endpoint' fail with Devin? Revision 1, last verified 2026-11-20T12:45:44Z. https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples (accessed 2026-11-21T10:02:44Z). @misc{LatestN_tool_devin_agents_and_automation_bad_instructions_examples_r1, title = {Why do vague instructions like 'Add a user stats endpoint' fail with Devin?}, author = {{LatestN}}, year = {2026}, howpublished = {\url{https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples}}, note = {Revision 1; digest sha256:2fa8c90b2c519930; last verified 2026-11-20T12:45:44Z; accessed 2026-11-21T10:02:44Z} } Reuse: License: CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) Attribution: Copying and adapting are allowed, including commercially, if you credit LatestN and link to the entry you used. Each entry ends with a ready-made citation. URL: https://latestn.com/tool/devin/agents-and-automation/bad-instructions-examples